If you’re getting ready for your first meeting with a premed advisor, you might be wondering what you’re actually supposed to ask. Should you bring up medical school requirements? Ask about research opportunities? Talk about your GPA? Or are you supposed to walk into the appointment and let your advisor guide the entire conversation?
I remember how overwhelming premed planning felt when I first started college. There are so many things you’re told you need to accomplish before medical school, including maintaining a strong GPA, preparing for the MCAT, completing clinical experience, volunteering, shadowing physicians, conducting research, and eventually applying. When you’re just beginning, it can be difficult to understand which activities deserve your attention first and which can wait until later.
The best questions to ask your premed advisor are about your required classes, academic timeline, clinical opportunities, research, volunteering, letters of recommendation, MCAT preparation, and your school’s medical school application process. I would also ask what opportunities your advisor knows about that you probably wouldn’t discover on your own.
Your advisor can be an excellent resource, particularly when it comes to opportunities and requirements specific to your university. However, I also think it’s important to understand what medical schools actually require so you can make informed decisions instead of following every recommendation without questioning it.
In this guide, I’ll walk you through the questions I recommend asking your premed advisor, how to prepare for your first appointment, and how to make the most of the advice you receive. I’ll also share what I found when researching discussions on Reddit and Student Doctor Network (SDN), along with guidance from medical school admissions professionals and experienced prehealth advisors.
If you’re just beginning college, I recommend keeping my Premed 4-Year Timeline and Checklist open while reading this article. It provides a year-by-year overview of the classes, experiences, and application milestones you’ll be discussing with your advisor.
What Does a Premed Advisor Actually Do?
A premed advisor, sometimes called a prehealth advisor, helps undergraduate students prepare for careers in medicine and other healthcare professions. Depending on your university, this may be a dedicated staff member, an academic advisor specializing in health professions, a faculty member, or an entire prehealth advising office.
Premed advisors commonly help students understand medical school prerequisites, plan their undergraduate coursework, identify extracurricular opportunities, and prepare for the application process. Some advising offices also coordinate letters of recommendation, conduct mock interviews, review personal statements, and organize informational sessions with medical school admissions representatives.
However, not every university provides the same advising services. Some colleges have large prehealth departments with multiple advisors, established physician connections, and extensive application support. Others may have one faculty member responsible for advising premedical students alongside teaching and research responsibilities.
That’s why one of the first questions I would ask is, “What services does our prehealth advising office provide, and which parts of the medical school application process am I responsible for managing myself?”
You may discover that your university offers resources you didn’t know existed. For example, some schools have relationships with local hospitals, maintain lists of research opportunities, offer MCAT preparation resources, or organize workshops specifically for students preparing to apply to medical school.
Your academic advisor and prehealth advisor may also be different people. Your academic advisor primarily helps you satisfy your degree requirements, while your prehealth advisor focuses on preparing you for professional school. Ideally, you’ll work with both to make sure your undergraduate degree and medical school prerequisites fit together.
What Should I Ask My Premed Advisor at My First Meeting?
For your first meeting, I would focus on understanding your academic requirements, your university’s resources, and what you should accomplish over the next year. You don’t need to walk into your first appointment with a complete medical school application plan, especially if you’re only a freshman.
I recommend beginning with a question like, “I’m interested in attending medical school, but I’m still learning about the process. Based on my major and where I am in college, what should I prioritize over the next two semesters?”
This gives your advisor an opportunity to understand your situation rather than immediately providing the same checklist they give every student. A freshman still adjusting to college probably needs different guidance than a junior preparing to take the MCAT.
I would also ask, “What are the most common mistakes premed students at our university make, and what would you recommend I do differently?”
I particularly like this question because your advisor may have worked with hundreds of students at your institution. They might know that students frequently struggle with a particular course sequence, miss deadlines for committee letters, or wait too long to begin searching for clinical opportunities.
Another useful question is, “Are there any opportunities or resources available to premed students here that I should know about?”
Don’t underestimate how helpful that can be. Your advisor may know professors who regularly accept undergraduate researchers, local physicians who have previously allowed students to shadow, or volunteer programs that have worked well for other premeds.
During freshman year, I would prioritize building a good academic foundation and gradually exploring medicine rather than trying to accomplish everything immediately. I discuss this in more detail in my Premed Freshman Year Checklist, which explains what I wish I’d understood when I first started college.
What Classes Should I Ask My Premed Advisor About?
One of the most important things your premed advisor can help you do is plan your prerequisite courses. Medical schools generally expect applicants to demonstrate preparation in subjects such as biology, chemistry, physics, and mathematics, but individual schools can have different requirements.
I would ask, “Which courses at our university satisfy common medical school prerequisites, and how should I schedule them over the next four years?”
Ideally, your advisor should help you create a tentative academic plan that accounts for your major, graduation requirements, and anticipated medical school application timeline. You want to avoid discovering during junior year that you’ve delayed a prerequisite course that is only offered during certain semesters.
For example, many students begin general chemistry and introductory biology during freshman year, take organic chemistry during sophomore year, and complete physics and biochemistry later. However, that sequence isn’t appropriate for every major or university. Some students may also need to account for calculus, statistics, writing courses, or additional laboratory requirements.
I would also ask whether taking multiple science classes together makes sense at your particular university. A semester with organic chemistry, physics, and another demanding laboratory course might be manageable for one student but unnecessarily difficult for another.
If you’re uncertain about your schedule, my article on What Classes Premeds Should Take Freshman Year includes sample schedules and explanations of how different prerequisites fit together.
Should I Ask About AP Credits, Community College Classes, and Pass/Fail Courses?
Absolutely. These questions are worth addressing before you register for classes because medical schools don’t all treat academic credits and prerequisites identically.
If you entered college with Advanced Placement credits, ask whether those credits satisfy your university’s premed requirements and whether you may need additional college-level coursework for certain medical schools. Some schools accept AP credit in particular circumstances, while others have more specific expectations.
I would also discuss community college classes, online courses, and pass/fail grading if any of those apply to you. Rather than relying on a general answer that every medical school will accept a particular course, ask your advisor to help you identify which schools have policies that could affect your plans.
You can verify individual school requirements using the AAMC’s Medical School Admission Requirements resources and official medical school admissions websites. I would especially recommend checking school-specific policies before making decisions that could limit where you eventually apply.
Should I Ask My Premed Advisor What Major to Choose?
Yes, particularly if you’re deciding between biology, chemistry, neuroscience, public health, psychology, engineering, or another major.
One question I recommend is, “Can I major in something I’m genuinely interested in while still completing the courses required for medical school?”
You do not need to major in biology to become a physician. Medical schools accept applicants from many academic backgrounds, provided they meet the appropriate admissions requirements and demonstrate academic readiness.
Your major should ideally be something you enjoy and can perform well in while still allowing you to complete the necessary prerequisites. I wouldn’t choose a major solely because you believe its title will impress an admissions committee.
For example, an engineering student may develop excellent analytical and problem-solving skills but need to plan carefully to fit organic chemistry, biology, and other premed prerequisites into an already demanding curriculum. A humanities major may have more flexibility in certain areas but need to arrange their science coursework deliberately.
I would ask your advisor to compare the actual course requirements for your preferred majors instead of simply recommending whichever major is most common among premed students at your university.
What Should I Ask My Premed Advisor About My GPA?
Your GPA is an important component of your medical school application, so I would discuss it with your advisor early rather than waiting until you’re close to applying.
A useful question is, “Based on my current academic performance, what should I be doing to remain competitive for medical school?”
For freshmen, the conversation may focus on developing effective study habits, balancing laboratory courses, and knowing when to use tutoring or office hours. For upperclassmen, it may involve reviewing academic trends, calculating the appropriate science GPA, or determining whether additional coursework would be beneficial.
I would also ask how your AMCAS GPA may differ from the GPA displayed on your university transcript. Medical school application services have their own policies for calculating academic averages, including how repeated courses are handled.
If you’ve earned a C, D, or F in a prerequisite, ask whether you should retake the course and how that decision might affect your academic preparation. Retaking a course doesn’t necessarily erase the original grade from your medical school application GPA, so it’s important to understand the relevant calculation policies before assuming it will.
I wouldn’t want students to feel that one difficult semester automatically ends their chances of becoming physicians. At the same time, it’s worth taking academic concerns seriously and creating an improvement plan while you still have time to demonstrate stronger performance.
When Should I Ask My Premed Advisor About the MCAT?
I recommend discussing your general MCAT timeline during freshman or sophomore year, although you usually don’t need to begin dedicated studying immediately.
The question I would ask is, “Based on my planned coursework and application year, when would you recommend taking the MCAT?”
Your MCAT timeline should account for the classes you need to complete, how long you’ll need to prepare, and when you intend to apply to medical school. Ideally, you’ll have completed most of the coursework covered by the exam before beginning intensive preparation.
If you’re planning to apply without taking a gap year, you’ll generally need to complete the MCAT earlier than someone who intends to apply after graduation. That can influence when you take organic chemistry, physics, biochemistry, psychology, and sociology.
I would also ask whether your university provides discounted MCAT preparation resources, practice examinations, workshops, or access to students who recently completed the exam.
When I prepared for the MCAT, I found that having a realistic study schedule and understanding my weaknesses was much more useful than collecting every resource other students recommended. Your advisor may be able to help with the timeline, but you’ll still need to determine which study methods work best for you.
If you’re approaching junior year, my Junior Year Premed Checklist explains how I would coordinate MCAT studying with classes, clinical experience, research, and preparing an application.
What Should I Ask My Premed Advisor About Clinical Experience?
This is one of the areas where I think your premed advisor can be especially helpful.
I would ask, “What clinical experience opportunities are available near our university, and which ones have previous students found most valuable?”
Clinical experience is important because medical schools want applicants who understand what working with patients and healthcare teams actually involves. There are several ways to gain that exposure, including medical assisting, scribing, nursing assistant positions, EMT work, hospice volunteering, hospital volunteering, and other patient-facing roles.
However, the availability of these opportunities varies considerably depending on where you attend college. A university near several hospitals may offer very different options from a smaller institution in a rural community.
Your advisor may know local healthcare organizations that regularly recruit undergraduates or clinics willing to work around student schedules. They may also know which opportunities require certifications, which provide training, and which offer paid positions.
I would specifically ask whether your school maintains relationships with hospitals, free clinics, or other healthcare organizations. Sometimes an opportunity is much easier to obtain through an established university connection than through cold emailing.
Before medical school, I worked in several clinical environments, including medical assisting roles. Those experiences helped me understand patient care and the responsibilities of healthcare professionals in ways I couldn’t have learned from classes alone.
I accumulated more than 2,000 hours of clinical experience, but I would never recommend treating my number as a requirement. I started working clinically early, and your opportunities and circumstances may be completely different.
My Clinical Experience Guide for Premeds explains the types of opportunities I recommend considering and how to find your first position. I also compare specific roles in my Premed Clinical Jobs Comparison Guide.
Can My Premed Advisor Help Me Find Physician Shadowing?
Your advisor may be one of the best people to ask about finding your first physician shadowing opportunity, especially if you don’t have family members or personal connections working in medicine.
I would ask, “Does our university have a physician shadowing program, or do you know physicians who have previously allowed premed students to shadow?”
Some advising offices maintain informal lists of physicians who are willing to work with undergraduate students. Others may have established shadowing programs or connections through university alumni.
Even if your advisor cannot arrange an opportunity directly, they may be able to recommend local hospitals, clinics, or physicians who have been receptive to students in the past.
I would also ask whether your university has policies regarding student shadowing, including confidentiality training, immunization requirements, background checks, or other onboarding procedures.
If you haven’t shadowed anyone yet, don’t feel embarrassed about asking where to begin. Many students struggle to find their first opportunity because they don’t know whom to contact.
You can also read my guide on What Counts as Shadowing for Medical School for an explanation of physician observation and how to approach potential opportunities.
I think it’s important to remember that shadowing is about understanding the physician’s responsibilities, not simply collecting hours. Spending time with a physician who explains their decisions and allows you to observe meaningful patient interactions can be much more educational than observing for many hours without learning very much.
What Should I Ask My Premed Advisor About Research Opportunities?
Research is another area where your advisor may have valuable university-specific connections.
I would ask, “Which professors or research laboratories regularly accept undergraduate students, and how would you recommend approaching them?”
Some students assume they need previous research experience before joining a laboratory, but many undergraduate researchers begin with very little technical knowledge. Professors often expect to train students who demonstrate genuine curiosity, reliability, and a willingness to learn.
Your advisor may know which professors have active projects, which departments offer undergraduate research programs, and when students should begin applying for summer research opportunities.
I would also ask whether your university provides research grants, summer fellowships, or opportunities to present projects at undergraduate research conferences.
During college, I became involved in both basic science and clinical research. Those experiences eventually helped me develop research skills, build relationships with mentors, present findings, and pursue additional opportunities.
Research was a major component of my own undergraduate experience, but I wouldn’t tell every premed that they need to replicate my path. The right research opportunity depends on your interests, available time, and the types of medical schools you’re considering.
If you’re starting from scratch, my article on How to Find Research as a Premed explains how to identify professors, approach laboratories, and find opportunities even without previous experience.
I would also ask your advisor whether research opportunities are available outside your major. Sometimes a student interested in medicine may discover meaningful research in psychology, public health, sociology, engineering, or another field they hadn’t originally considered.
What Should I Ask My Premed Advisor About Volunteering?
Medical schools value service, and your advisor may be familiar with organizations where undergraduates can become meaningfully involved.
A useful question is, “What volunteer organizations near campus would allow me to serve consistently and develop meaningful responsibilities?”
I would distinguish between volunteering that provides clinical exposure and volunteering focused on serving the broader community. Both can be valuable, but they may demonstrate different experiences and motivations.
For example, volunteering in a hospital might introduce you to healthcare environments, while tutoring underserved students, working with a food pantry, or helping at a community organization could expose you to challenges affecting people outside clinical settings.
I would also ask whether your university has service organizations that maintain long-term relationships with local communities. Joining an established organization can make it easier to become involved consistently rather than spending months trying to arrange individual volunteer experiences.
I generally recommend choosing service opportunities that you care about rather than selecting activities solely because they sound impressive.
If you’re already accumulating clinical hours through paid employment, your volunteering doesn’t necessarily need to occur in a hospital. My guide on Clinical vs. Nonclinical Volunteering for Medical School explains how these experiences can complement each other.
What Extracurricular Activities Should I Ask My Premed Advisor About?
You don’t need to participate in every premed club, honor society, leadership organization, and research program available on campus.
Instead, I would ask, “Which student organizations or extracurricular opportunities have helped previous premed students develop meaningful skills and experiences?”
Your advisor may know which clubs provide opportunities to lead projects, organize service events, meet physicians, participate in professional development activities, or connect with students who have successfully applied to medical school.
I would also ask whether your university hosts medical school admissions presentations, application workshops, or networking events with healthcare professionals.
When evaluating an organization, I would consider what you’ll actually be doing rather than focusing exclusively on the organization’s name. A student who spends several years leading meaningful projects may have more to discuss than someone who joins numerous organizations but participates very little.
The same principle applies to leadership. You don’t need to become president of every club you join, but it’s worth seeking opportunities where you can take responsibility, solve problems, and contribute to something meaningful.
For a broader overview, I have an entire Premed Extracurriculars Guide covering service, leadership, research, and other opportunities that can help you develop throughout college.
What Should I Ask My Premed Advisor About Letters of Recommendation?
I would strongly encourage students to learn about their university’s recommendation letter process well before their application year.
One of the most important questions is, “Does our university provide a prehealth committee letter, and what are the requirements and deadlines for receiving one?”
A committee letter is an institutional evaluation prepared by a prehealth committee or advising office. Depending on the university, it may incorporate information from individual faculty recommendations, interviews, academic records, and other materials.
Not every undergraduate institution offers committee letters, and medical schools have different policies for evaluating them. If your university doesn’t provide one, you can generally submit individual letters according to the requirements of the schools where you apply.
However, if your university does offer committee letters, you need to understand its process before you’re ready to submit your application.
Some advising offices require students to complete internal applications, submit essays, attend interviews, provide recommendations, or meet eligibility criteria before receiving an institutional letter. These requirements can have deadlines much earlier than the actual medical school application.
I would also ask, “Which professors should I be developing relationships with now so that I can request strong letters when I apply?”
I recommend getting to know professors who can genuinely evaluate your academic abilities, work ethic, curiosity, and character. That doesn’t mean you need to become close friends with your instructors, but you should give them opportunities to observe your engagement and growth.
Attend office hours when you need help, ask thoughtful questions, participate in class, and consider working with faculty members on research or other academic projects.
A detailed letter from someone who knows your abilities well can be more informative than a generic recommendation from someone with an impressive title.
One additional question I would ask is whether your advising office stores recommendation letters for future application cycles. This may be useful if you graduate before applying or plan to take one or more gap years.
When Should I Apply to Medical School, and Should I Take a Gap Year?
This is an important conversation to have once you’ve made progress through your undergraduate coursework and begun developing your extracurricular experiences.
I would ask, “Based on my current academic record, clinical experiences, and anticipated MCAT timeline, do you think applying without a gap year is realistic?”
Your advisor should help you evaluate whether you’ll have enough time to complete your prerequisites, prepare for the MCAT, develop meaningful experiences, obtain recommendation letters, and prepare your application.
I would encourage you to be open to different timelines. Applying immediately after junior year may work very well for students who have completed the necessary preparation, but other students may benefit from additional time.
A gap year can provide opportunities to gain more clinical experience, participate in research, improve academic preparation, save money, or simply approach the application process with greater confidence.
I wouldn’t recommend taking a gap year automatically, but I also wouldn’t rush an application because you feel pressured to follow the same timeline as your classmates.
My article on Whether You Should Take a Gap Year Before Medical School goes into the factors I would consider when deciding whether to apply immediately or spend additional time preparing.
What Should I Ask My Premed Advisor Before Applying to Medical School?
Once you’re approaching your application year, your advising appointments should become much more individualized.
I would bring an updated transcript, activity list, anticipated or actual MCAT score, and a preliminary list of medical schools you’re considering.
Then I would ask, “Looking at my application as a whole, what are my strongest areas, and which weaknesses should I address before applying?”
This is more useful than asking whether your GPA alone is competitive or whether you have enough research hours. Medical schools evaluate applicants using multiple factors, and your advisor may be able to identify imbalances that aren’t obvious when you examine each part separately.
For example, you might have a strong GPA and substantial research experience but relatively little exposure to patients. Alternatively, you may have extensive clinical experience and community service but need to demonstrate stronger academic preparation.
I would also ask whether your advisor can help you develop a realistic medical school list. They may have historical information about students from your university who were admitted to particular programs, although previous outcomes cannot guarantee your own admission.
Your school list should account for academic competitiveness, state residency, program mission, geographic preferences, prerequisites, and other factors.
I would also ask about the financial side of applying. Application fees, MCAT preparation, interview-related costs, and other expenses can add up quickly, so it’s worth learning about institutional resources and assistance programs before your application cycle begins.
What Have Medical School Admissions Officers Said About Preparing to Apply?
I wanted to include perspectives from people who have worked in admissions because their guidance can help you understand what your advisor should be preparing you to demonstrate.
I reviewed guidance from the Association of American Medical Colleges, including its discussion of how medical schools review applications.
In that article, Irene Tise, identified as an admissions officer at Wake Forest School of Medicine, discusses the importance of successfully completing challenging science coursework and demonstrating academic readiness through MCAT performance. Lori Nicolaysen, identified as a former assistant dean of admissions at Weill Cornell Medical College, emphasizes personal initiative as another quality admissions committees value.
I think these observations are especially useful when you’re deciding what to ask your advisor. Your goal shouldn’t simply be to find out which courses and activities are technically required. You should also understand how your choices can help demonstrate that you’re prepared for medical school and committed to the responsibilities of becoming a physician.
For example, instead of asking only how many research hours you need, you might ask whether your current research experience demonstrates curiosity, persistence, and the ability to work through problems. Instead of focusing exclusively on how many clinical hours you’ve accumulated, you might ask whether you’ve had enough meaningful patient exposure to explain why you want to practice medicine.
I also reviewed the American Medical Association’s article, Top 4 Questions to Ask Your Premed Adviser.
The article features Jo Scullion, who was serving as an assistant director for health careers and biosciences at the University of California, Berkeley Career Center. Scullion encourages students to pursue activities that genuinely interest them rather than selecting experiences only to improve their resumes.
She also discusses evaluating an applicant’s academic performance, clinical exposure, research, and community service while recognizing that students may need different amounts of time to become ready to apply.
I particularly agree with her emphasis on meaningful experiences. If you’re spending hours volunteering somewhere but learning very little or contributing almost nothing, I would talk with your advisor about finding an opportunity that better fits your interests and goals.
Another perspective comes from Emil Chuck, PhD, an experienced health professions advisor and former admissions professional who has written extensively about prehealth advising and committee letters. In his Student Doctor Network article, How to Work with Pre-Health Advisors and Committees, he emphasizes that students should develop relationships with advisors early, arrive prepared with questions, and maintain communication throughout the application process.
His discussion also highlights something students sometimes overlook: prehealth advisors may have institutional experience and relationships that can help them understand application expectations beyond what is written in a course catalog.
My interpretation of these perspectives is that a productive advising relationship should involve more than checking whether you’ve completed a list of requirements. Your advisor should help you identify where you’re developing as an applicant, where you need additional experience, and how your academic and extracurricular choices fit together.
What Premed Students on Reddit and Student Doctor Network Say About Premed Advisors
I also searched Reddit, including r/premed, and reviewed Student Doctor Network discussions about premed advising appointments, unreliable advice, recommendation letters, and students’ experiences working with university advisors.
I wanted to understand what students actually found useful because the questions that come up in these communities aren’t always addressed in formal university advising guides.
The discussions revealed several recurring concerns, particularly about whether advisors provide personalized guidance, how helpful they are for finding opportunities, and what students should do when they receive conflicting advice.
These forums are valuable for understanding other applicants’ experiences, but I wouldn’t treat anonymous comments as authoritative medical school admissions policies. I recommend using them to identify concerns worth discussing with your advisor and then verifying important requirements through official sources.
What I Found on Reddit and r/premed
In the r/premed discussion 1st Meeting with PreMed Advisor Today. Anything Important I Should Ask?, a commenter recommended focusing on information specific to the student’s university.
The suggestions included asking where to find clinical experiences and local volunteering opportunities and whether the advising office has specific requirements for providing committee letters.
I agree with that approach because information about general medical school prerequisites is relatively easy to find online. Information about which local physicians accept shadowing students or which research laboratories are recruiting undergraduates can be much harder to discover.
I also reviewed the discussion What Questions Should I Ask My College’s Prehealth Advising Center?.
Commenters suggested asking whether advisors could help build a course schedule, connect students with successful applicants or alumni, review resumes, identify MCAT preparation resources, and recommend shadowing programs.
One commenter also emphasized that students don’t need to understand the entire medical school application process before making an appointment. They can begin by asking for an overview and return later with more specific questions.
I think that advice is particularly helpful for freshmen. You shouldn’t feel like you need to become an expert on medical school admissions before speaking with someone whose job is to help you understand the process.
Another theme I noticed in r/premed discussions was skepticism about the quality of advice students received. Some commenters described being discouraged from applying, receiving overly general recommendations, or hearing claims that didn’t seem consistent with official admissions requirements.
I would take those experiences seriously without assuming that every prehealth advisor provides poor guidance. Some advisors are excellent and have years of experience helping students navigate the application process, while others may have less specialized training or limited institutional resources.
If you receive advice that could substantially affect your application, such as being told that a particular course will never be accepted or that your GPA makes admission impossible, ask for the basis of that recommendation and verify school-specific requirements before making a final decision.
What I Found on Student Doctor Network
I also reviewed Student Doctor Network discussions about premedical advisors, committee letters, and the value of developing an advising relationship early.
In the discussion Premed Advisors: Worth Listening To or Not?, students shared conflicting experiences. Some expressed frustration with discouraging or overly restrictive recommendations, while others defended advisors who had significant experience working with successful medical school applicants.
One commenter raised an important consideration: students should be cautious about automatically trusting anonymous internet advice over someone who may have spent years advising applicants and developing relationships with medical school admissions offices.
I agree with that. Sometimes your advisor will tell you something you don’t want to hear, and that doesn’t necessarily make the advice incorrect.
For example, if you have limited clinical experience, a relatively weak academic record, and no recommendation letters lined up, your advisor may reasonably suggest delaying your application. That recommendation might be disappointing, but it’s worth considering carefully.
I also examined SDN discussions about committee letters, including the 2024–2025 Official Letters of Evaluation Questions Thread.
These conversations illustrate how confusing recommendation-letter requirements can become. Students ask about institutional committee letters, individual faculty recommendations, submission procedures, and differences between school-specific requirements.
Several questions require information that only the student’s advising office or the medical school itself can definitively provide.
For that reason, I would make committee-letter procedures one of your highest priorities during an advising appointment, even if you aren’t applying for another year or two.
My Takeaways From the Reddit and SDN Discussions
After reviewing these conversations, I think the most useful approach is to treat your premed advisor as an important resource without assuming that every recommendation is universally applicable.
Your advisor may have substantial experience with students at your university, know local opportunities that are difficult to find independently, and understand institutional application requirements that could affect your timeline.
At the same time, medical schools establish their own admissions requirements, and those policies can change. It’s reasonable to ask questions, seek clarification, and verify important information using official school websites and AAMC resources.
I also think students should recognize that a productive advising relationship develops over time. Your first meeting might focus on coursework, while your later appointments may involve research, clinical experience, recommendations, and application strategy.
The students who benefit most from advising are often those who arrive prepared, communicate openly, follow through on recommendations, and return when they have new questions or decisions to make.
How Do I Prepare for My First Premed Advisor Meeting?
I recommend spending approximately 15 to 30 minutes preparing before your appointment. You don’t need an elaborate presentation or a perfectly organized resume, but having a few materials ready can make the conversation much more productive.
Start by reviewing your current course schedule, major requirements, and the classes you’ve already completed. If possible, bring a copy of your unofficial transcript and a tentative plan for the next few semesters.
I would also prepare a brief summary of your extracurricular experiences, even if you haven’t done very much yet. Your advisor may ask whether you’ve volunteered, shadowed physicians, participated in research, or worked in a healthcare setting.
Don’t feel pressured to exaggerate your accomplishments. If you’ve never participated in research or don’t know how to begin volunteering, that is exactly the type of information your advisor needs to help you.
Before the meeting, identify two or three questions that are particularly important to you. You can certainly bring more, but it’s helpful to know which concerns you want to resolve before the appointment ends.
For example, a freshman might prioritize choosing next semester’s classes and finding an initial volunteer opportunity. A sophomore might want to discuss joining a research laboratory and determining when to take biochemistry. A junior may need to decide whether to take the MCAT in the spring or delay their application.
I would also ask whether your advisor can recommend an upperclassman or recent graduate who successfully navigated the premed process at your university. Students who have recently completed the same courses or joined the same research programs may offer practical insights that complement formal advising.
After your meeting, write down the recommendations you received and any deadlines you need to remember. You can incorporate those plans into my Premed 4-Year Timeline and Checklist, which includes a free spreadsheet for tracking coursework, extracurricular activities, MCAT preparation, and application milestones.
How Often Should I Meet With My Premed Advisor?
I recommend meeting with your premed advisor at least once per semester when possible, particularly during your first two years of college.
A semesterly meeting gives you an opportunity to review your academic progress, discuss new opportunities, and make adjustments before small planning problems become more difficult to address.
During freshman year, you might focus on coursework, study habits, and learning about the opportunities available at your university. During sophomore year, you can begin discussing more consistent clinical experience, research, service, and your anticipated MCAT timeline.
By junior year, your meetings may become more frequent because you’ll have more significant decisions to make about application readiness, recommendation letters, school selection, and whether a gap year would be helpful.
Your advisor may also recommend specific appointment schedules depending on how their office operates. Some universities have formal advising milestones or required workshops for students planning to apply to medical school.
If you’re currently in your second year, my Sophomore Year Premed Checklist can help you identify the topics worth discussing during your next appointment.
What If My Premed Advisor Gives Me Bad Advice?
You may occasionally receive advice that seems inconsistent with information you’ve read elsewhere. This doesn’t automatically mean your advisor is wrong, but it’s reasonable to investigate before making an important decision.
I would begin by asking, “Is that a requirement for all medical schools, a policy at particular schools, or a recommendation based on your experience with previous applicants?”
Those are very different categories of advice.
For example, your advisor might recommend completing additional upper-level science courses if your academic record needs improvement. That’s an individualized recommendation rather than a universal prerequisite imposed by every medical school.
Similarly, an advisor might suggest accumulating more clinical experience before applying. That recommendation could be appropriate if you have very limited patient exposure, even though there isn’t one national minimum number of clinical hours required by every medical school.
If the question involves an official requirement, consult the appropriate application service or the medical school’s published admissions policies.
I would also seek another perspective when making major decisions about your application. That might involve speaking with another advisor, a medical school admissions representative, or someone with relevant experience who understands your situation.
However, I wouldn’t dismiss advice simply because it’s discouraging. Sometimes being told that you need to improve your GPA, gain more clinical experience, or delay your application is exactly the feedback that helps you become a stronger applicant.
What If My College Doesn’t Have a Premed Advisor?
If your university doesn’t offer dedicated prehealth advising, you can still create a strong medical school preparation plan.
I would begin by speaking with your academic advisor about degree requirements and identifying faculty members familiar with students pursuing healthcare careers. Professors in biology, chemistry, psychology, public health, and other departments may be able to help you find research opportunities or connect with relevant mentors.
You can also contact nearby medical schools to ask whether they offer informational sessions, applicant resources, or outreach programs for undergraduates. These events can help you learn directly from admissions representatives and current medical students.
The AAMC provides extensive information about medical school prerequisites, applications, MCAT preparation, and other aspects of the admissions process. Its official resources are particularly important if you don’t have someone at your university helping you verify requirements.
For broader planning, I recommend starting with my AspiringMD Premed Guides. I created this website to make the medical school preparation process easier to understand, especially for students who don’t have personal connections to physicians or medical students.
You can also build relationships with classmates, professors, research mentors, and healthcare professionals. A strong support network doesn’t have to come entirely from a formal advising office.
Frequently Asked Questions About Premed Advising
Is It Too Early to Meet With a Premed Advisor During Freshman Year?
No, freshman year is an excellent time to begin meeting with a premed advisor. You can discuss your prerequisite courses, degree requirements, and opportunities for clinical experience, volunteering, and research.
You don’t need to have an impressive resume or even a completely finalized major before your first appointment. Beginning early gives you more time to make adjustments and develop a realistic plan for the rest of college.
What Should I Bring to My First Premed Advisor Appointment?
I recommend bringing your current course schedule, an unofficial transcript if available, your intended major, and a short list of questions. If you’ve already participated in volunteering, research, or clinical experiences, you can also bring a brief summary of those activities.
You don’t need a formal resume unless your advising office specifically requests one. The goal is to give your advisor enough information to understand where you are and what decisions you need help making.
Can My Premed Advisor Tell Me My Chances of Getting Into Medical School?
Your advisor may be able to provide a general assessment of your academic preparation and application competitiveness, particularly if they have experience working with students who applied to similar programs.
However, no advisor can guarantee admission or accurately predict every admissions decision. Medical schools evaluate applicants using multiple factors, and a student’s fit with a particular institution can influence the outcome.
I would ask your advisor to identify specific strengths and weaknesses in your application rather than focusing exclusively on whether they think you’ll get accepted.
Do I Need a Premed Advisor to Apply to Medical School?
No, having a premed advisor is not a universal requirement for applying to medical school. You can prepare your application independently and use official admissions resources to verify prerequisites and application procedures.
However, if your undergraduate institution provides committee letters or other formal application services, you should understand whether those resources affect your application requirements or timeline.
Can a Premed Advisor Help Me Get Into Research?
Yes, your advisor may know professors who regularly recruit undergraduate researchers, departments with research programs, or summer opportunities available to students at your university.
They may also be able to connect you with other students who have research experience. I would still recommend independently researching laboratories that interest you and contacting professors directly when appropriate.
Can My Premed Advisor Help Me Find Clinical Experience or Shadowing?
Potentially, yes. Some advising offices maintain connections with local physicians, hospitals, clinics, and community organizations that have previously accepted undergraduate students.
However, not every advisor can arrange clinical experiences directly. Even when they cannot provide a placement, they may be able to recommend organizations to contact or explain how previous students found opportunities.
Should I Meet With My Premed Advisor Before Registering for Classes?
Yes, especially if you’re entering freshman year, changing majors, transferring colleges, or planning to take courses that could affect your medical school prerequisites.
Meeting before registration can help you avoid scheduling conflicts, missed prerequisites, and difficult course combinations. I would also review your academic plan periodically rather than assuming the schedule you developed during freshman year will remain appropriate throughout college.
My Final Advice on Meeting With Your Premed Advisor
I think one of the best things you can do as a beginning premed is establish a relationship with your advisor early, even if you don’t have many questions yet.
You have several years of coursework, experiences, and decisions ahead of you. Having someone who understands your university’s resources and can help you navigate that process can make college much less confusing.
At the same time, I encourage you to take ownership of your medical school preparation. Learn about the application process yourself, ask questions when recommendations don’t make sense, and seek out opportunities that genuinely interest you.
I would also avoid comparing your progress too closely with other premeds. You may meet students who already have research positions, extensive shadowing experience, or detailed MCAT schedules during their first semester of college. Their experiences don’t mean you’re behind, and you don’t need to follow an identical path.
If you’re just beginning, start with my Freshman Year Premed Checklist and First-Year Premed Course Guide. These will help you develop an academic plan and identify reasonable priorities during your first year.
As you progress, my Sophomore Year Premed Checklist and Junior Year Premed Checklist can help you prepare for more advanced coursework, clinical experiences, research, and the MCAT. Once you’re approaching graduation, my Fourth Year Premed Checklist explains how to continue strengthening your application and prepare for the transition to medical school.
You can always return to my main Premed 4-Year Timeline and Checklist to see how everything fits together.
Before your next advising appointment, choose the three questions that would make the biggest difference in your current situation. Bring them with you, take notes on the answers, and identify one or two concrete things you can accomplish before your next meeting.
Over time, those small conversations and decisions can help you build an application that reflects your academic preparation, genuine interests, and experiences rather than simply a checklist of activities you thought medical schools wanted to see.

